PHIL 126 Spring 2013 Paradoxes (W)

Also offered Fall 2012

There are three grains of sand on my desk. This is unfortunate, but at least there isn't a heap of sand on my desk. That would be really worrisome. On the other hand, there is a heap of sand in my backyard. I don't know how exactly how many grains of sand are in this heap, but let's say 100,000. My daughter removes one grain of sand. I don't know why, she just does. It seems like there is still a heap of sand in my backyard. In fact, it seems like you can't change a heap of sand into something that isn't a heap of sand by removing one grain of sand. Right? But now we have a problem. By repeated application of the same reasoning, it seems that even after she removes 99,997 grains of sand--I don't know what she wants with all this sand, but I'm starting to worry about that girl--there is still a heap of sand in my backyard. But three grains isn't enough for a heap. So there is not a heap in my backyard. Now I'm confused. Where did my reasoning go wrong? What we have here is an example of the sorites paradox. It is a paradox, because I started with seemingly true statements and used valid reasoning to arrive at contradictory conclusions. We can learn a lot about logic, language, epistemology and metaphysics by thinking through and attempting to resolve paradoxes. In this class, we'll work together to think through some ancient and contemporary paradoxes. We'll also work on writing lucid prose that displays precisely the logical structure of arguments, engages in focused critique of these arguments, and forcefully presents arguments of our own. Other topics could include: Zeno's paradoxes of motion and plurality, the liar's paradox, the surprise exam paradox, paradoxes of material constitution, Newcomb's Problem , and the Prisoner's Dilemma.
Class Format: seminar
Requirements/Evaluation: several short writing assignments and a longer final paper
Additional Info:
Additional Info2:
Prerequisites: none
Enrollment Preference: first- and second-year students
Department Notes:
Material and Lab Fees:
Distribution Notes:
Divisional Attributes: Division II,Writing Intensive
Other Attributes:
Enrollment Limit: 19
Expected Enrollment: 19
Class Number: 3392
PHIL126-01(S) SEM Paradoxes (W) Division 2: Social StudiesWriting Intensive Keith E. McPartland
TF 1:10 PM-2:25 PM Griffin 1 3392
Course Search
Catalog Number:
Subject Attributes:
Enrollment Limit:
Course Type:
Start Time: End Time:
Instructor First Name:
Instructor Last Name:
Keyword Search: